Tuesday, October 08, 2024

The Least of Us, by Sam Qionones, a Brief Review

 The Least of Us is Sam Quinones' second venture into the crisis of drugs and death that began with the prescription opioid epidemic that grew under the national radar for so many years. I read Dreamland after hearing Quinones speak at a medical conference. While I felt like I knew a lot of the background of Dreamland due to my employment in the workers' compensation industry (as a non-clinician), I nonetheless found it helpful in filling in my knowledge gaps. As more recent developments related to fentanyl and meth have greater involvement of street drugs, my knowledge is not as extensive. This book proved extremely helpful in bringing me up to speed.


Quinones weaves individual stories of abuse, addiction, and enablement with analysis and additional tales that offer hope. While the book does offer stories of individuals and communities that are learning to respond helpfully to the crisis, many of the accounts are sad and tragic -- don't read this while depressed. Quinones does not flinch at the enormous toll of cheap, highly addictive, and harmful drugs on individuals, families and communities. He also does not flinch in placing much blame on the start of the pandemic (the prescription drug part) on pharmaceutical companies. He is rightly scathing with regard to the role of Oxycontin maker Purdue Pharmacy and the Sackler family in laying the groundwork for all that has followed.

That said, there are heroes in this book. Interestingly, this is not a political work. Other than a brief mention of added resources made available via Obamacare, Quinones seems uninterested in what is happening in state or federal capitols. Instead, the heroes tend to be in communities where diverse groups of people realize what is happening around them and creatively begin to address them. Quinones never reveals his own political biases (he mentions the benefits of a capitalism reined in by a moral sense), but I would guess him to be center-left. This is interesting in that he goes out of his way to praise the work of political conservatives who get things right and make progress in this fight in their communities.

Quinones also describes himself as a non-Christian, but again he goes out of his way to praise Christians and churches that are making positive efforts to help individuals and families. Much of the narrative takes place in Appalachia, where there are plenty of Christians and conservatives to talk about. That he finds helpful stories, perhaps from people that he disagrees with on other things, shows Quinones to be more interested in promoting solutions than tribes. I consider this to be a strength of the book.

The author is on shakier ground when he extends the findings of neuroscience to reveal a widespread addiction problem across broad sectors of American life. Regardless of what one thinks about his conclusions in this area, the development of this narrative is not as well researched or compelling as the rest of the book.

That weakness aside, this is a work that I will highly recommend to friends and colleagues. I have previously recommended Dreamland to anyone interested in this crisis, and The Least of Us stands as a worthy successor.

Tuesday, January 02, 2024

Christian Nationalism Without Christ

 For decades Christians with whom I share many sympathies have warned about the emergence of a Christless Christianity among American evangelicals. In the last decade the reality of an advocacy of Christianity without Christ has seemed to increase as Christians have seemed willing to desire the restoration of Christendom even if it involves the abandonment of the Son of God. Consider the following:

  • In the last year or so Christians have invested significant time and treasure in a campaign to sell to the American public a version of Jesus that resembles the heresy of Socianism more than it looks like Jesus Christ as described in the New Testament. Stripped of any message of his divinity or his saving mission, Americans are supposed to be impressed that "he gets us," though it remains unclear why it should matter.to anyone.
  • A nationally known Christian talking head was recently heard by this correspondent to say that the Bible actually has "little to say" about salvation, though it provides a lot of information relevant to the development of a "Christian worldview." Evidently, the core affirmation of the Christian religion that God saves sinners, a notion that suffuses the Bible from Genesis to Revelation, is in fact remarkably absent after all and not important to whatever worldview that requires developing.
  • In a lecture on Christian nationalism before an academic evangelical audience, listeners were assured that Abraham Lincoln was certainly a "Christian nationalist" even though it was admitted that it is unclear whether the 16th president would affirm a single phrase from the Apostle's Creed. Seemingly, Christian nationalism doesn't require any clear doctrinal confession -- not even the opening phrase of belief in "God the Father almighty."
  • Recently, a woman who had been victimized as a girl by radical versions of Islam before embracing atheism has now announced her conversion to Christianity. I need to state that I hope she truly has come to faith in Christ, as her story is a striking one of great courage. What is unclear from her written statements, however, is whether her conversion involves faith in the saving work of Christ. She seems more concerned about the capacity of Christian ethics and perhaps theism to provide a foundation for a humanitarian societal ethic. Many evangelicals seem enthused.
These types of examples seem to point toward the embrace of Christendom and Christianity without Christ, of evangelicalism without the evangel. Advocates seem to want to point to legal structures embracing moralistic commitments as a foundation for "taking America back," though it is unclear what they are taking it back for. Somehow, no one talking about a Christian nation is advocating replacing the Star Spangled Banner with the Nicene Creed or the vague "In God We Trust" with a pronouncement that justification is by faith alone.

None of this is to deny that there are negative trends taking place in culture, but the culture cannot be reclaimed by a church that has lost track of the Gospel. The real need of the day is not the reclamation of the culture as much as the reformation of the church. The former is unlikely apart from the realization of the latter.

Monday, January 01, 2024

Books Read 2023


Fiction 


1.      William F. Buckley, Jr., See you Later, Alligator

2.      Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo *

3.      Mikhail Bulgakov, The Master and the Margarita *

4.      William F. Buckley, Jr., High Jinx

5.      Scott Turow, Suspect

6.      Anthony Trollope, Phineas Finn *

Nonfiction

7.      Michael P. Winship, Hot Protestants: a History of Puritanism in England and America

8.      David D. Hall, The Puritans: a Transatlantic History *

9.      Thomas S. Kidd, Who Is an Evangelical?

10.  Charles Malcolm Wingard, Help for the New Pastor

11.  Cailin O’Connor and James Owen Weatherall, The Misinformation Age

12.  Millard J. Erickson, ed., Readings in Christian Theology, Vol. 1: The Living God

13.  Shelby Foote, The Civil War (Volume 2) *

14.  Keith A. Mathison, The Lord’s Supper

15.  Richard Ganz, Psychobabble

16.  David VanDrunen, God’s Glory Alone *

17.  Kim Riddlebarger, The Man of Sin *

18.  Scott David Allen, Why Social Justice Is not Biblical Justice

19.  Grant Macaskill, Autism and the Church

20.  Gene Edwards Veith, Jr., God at Work

21.  D.G. Hart, Sean Michael Lucas, and Stephen J. Nichols, eds. The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards *

22.  Anthony A. Hoekema, The Bible and the Future *

23.  Kenneth L. Gentry, Jr., Before Jerusalem Fell

24.  W. Andrew Hoffecker, Charles Hodge: the Pride of Princeton

25.  Stephen J. Nichols, R.C. Sproul: a Life *

26.  John Stott, The Cross of Christ *

27.  William R. Edwards, John C.A. Ferguson, and Chad Van Dixhorn, eds., Theology for Ministry

28.  Geoffrey Robertson, The Tyrannicide Brief *

29.  Carl Bridenbaugh, Mitre and Sceptre

30.  J. Gresham Machen, Christianity and Liberalism *

31.  Shelby Foote, The Civil War (Volume 3) *

32.  R.J. Rushdoony, The Sermon on the Mount

33.  Roosevelt Montas, Rescuing Socrates

34.  Iain Murray, The Puritan Hope

35.  J.V. Fesko, Adam and the Covenant of Works *

36.  Michael Horton, Recovering our Sanity *

37.  Edward Taylor, Upon the Types of the Old Testament (Vol. 1)

38.  Edward Taylor, Upon the Types of the Old Testament (Vol. 1I)


* -- highly recommended